Whatever you do, don't get yourself down from online dating. All you're seeing is a tiny tiny tiny selection of girls in your local area. Go to town on a night out and you'll see hundreds more girls, remember not all the single girls are on that site. So in other words try not to put too much of your life effort in to it. Go out. Hang with friends. Do day game. Night game. Don't use POF as a substitute alone. Don't make it the be all and end all
As for your profile, I came in to this tread to say online dating is 90% based on pictures and if you have bad ones you'll get nowhere but yours are pretty good.
Code:
There's something very special about you. You are curious about the world
around you. You can take a joke and are not easily offended. You believe that
sarcasm is a spice of life. You can spell (without using spell check), and are
generally happy.
You want to see the world and travel, love to kiss, you cuddle
like a cat on the sofa, and shag like a tiger in bed.
You are thin, athletic, (curvy in the right places is a plus), your eyes are bright and convey the depth of your
spirit. You are beautiful inside and out, and you think you can actually keep up
with me.
The rest is negotiable. (well, you can’t be a blood relative).
I'd maybe revise this or get rid of it. I used to have clauses on mine. what I'm looking for. What the girl must be etc. If anything I found it a hindrance as there's allready enough for woman to judge you on without giving them more excuses not to reply.
As for your messages. Don't use any canned stuff whatsoever. Read their profile and pick up a few things on there that you can also relate to. Keep it short and ask 1-2 questions so they have a reason to respond.
Here's my typical template (this was sent to a girl who mentioned she liked art on her profile.
Quote:
Hey what's up

I can't say I'm a massive fan of the kind of art they have at the Tate or what the whole Turner Prize is about but other than that I'm a big appreciater of real art ha. Do you ever visit design-milk.com best site ever if you don't!
You seem pretty cool, but what else you got going on for you other than art?

I'm devi4nt by the way. Would be cool to hear back if you want to chat x
I know most on here will say that's bullshit but I used to get ZERO results when I tried the Pick up ways or tried to be over sexual/cocky. Now I get 90% success rate with simple messages that show that I've read their profile and have some interest. You can increase the sexual content later in the conversation. Obviously I tailor that message to different girls. I rely heavily on what they have on their profiles. Girls who write 'I don't know what to say here' or 'If I say it all here there won't be anything to talk about' are down right BORING and don't deserve my message. The only opener I have for them is 'hi' and that's about as interesting as the conversation would ever get.
Remember: Lighthearted and fun. I have a rule for texts where I always send a follow up but online is so ruthless I never send a follow up. If she ignores me or stops speaking to me she's found someone else. It's sadly all a numbers game online which is why you should have fun with it.
My eye opener came when I set up a fake profile with some model guys photos and I watched the messages roll in. Fat girls messaging thinking they have a chance. The girls who say 'don't just say hi' on their profile messaging me saying just 'hi'. It's laughable. The girls on there get so many messages they have become conditioned to up their standards ridiculously. If you approached all the girls you messaged on there in real life I'm sure 99% would respond positively. So try not to get too bogged down in it all. It's not you. It's them
Anyway hope that helps somewhat. Good luck man.