What do I know. Ive only scored several hundred girls, been married at an extremely young age (looong story, involves romance, young love, and international immigration laws), and am generally seen by my friends and colleagues as the man to go to when it comes to getting the girl.
Being a mPUA doesnt mean to be an asshole. You really should leave a girl better off for having met you than when you first found her. That shit gets around. As well, if you are a rude prick who ignores common social cues and boundaries, you simply arent going to get very far with women. I am not talking about being an AFC chump, or anything like that. But there are still things you do and do not do. One of the things you should avoid is putting your foot square in your mouth and trampling all over somebody's emotions.
Women are very observant over these things; they put an extremely high value on it and it is a massive DLV if you show her a total lack of social grace.
So yeah, if you think you never should apologize, well, you got another thing coming, pal. Apologizing when you clearly made a mistake takes balls. It takes intelligence as well, to realize you have made the mistake. Of course, it's a lot easier to just not make those mistakes in the first place, but then there probably wouldnt be a lot of people asking for help on these forums, would there?
This guy, imho, made some pretty serious blunders with this girl, tho it is hard to tell from a short post without being there, but I am pretty damn sure. I am also sure that if she has any sense of self worth or confidence, as most decent girls do, then she isnt going to be hopping all over him next time he isolates her and tries to figure out if she is "really just a closet slut" as you so eloquently put it.
Yes, he could sarge her straight down to nothing, apologize for nothing, maybe if she is really weak he could even fuck her. Why bother? Why not just toss some rohipnol in her drink? It would be the same result afterwards. Massive resentment and buyers remorse, no chance for anything more than a one nighter (and a small chance at that). And she would probably tell her friends what a magnanimous prick he is. So scratch her friends off the to-do list as well.
As for the qualifying, she was forced into it directly by the bluntness of his approach. Almost any girl is going to do this, it hardly gets you any kind of score points if you push her into this kind of automatic defensive posture. The trick is to use finese, subtlety, to get the girl to qualify
when she really doesnt need to. Now if she had been extremely high value, she would have told him to fuck off. But this girl is just a normal nice person, and he stomped her, and as well he burned his recovery by alienating himself and then breaking contact off.
If what he did was so "the right way" to do it, why didnt she qualify herself when it really mattered, at the end, when he unfortunately offered up the point that they had nothing in common? If there was ANY semblance of attraction here at this point, she would have argued against him. "Oh thats not true, we both blah blah blah." But she didn't, did she? She agreed and let him walk away. Doesn't seem like his game was working all that well, does it? Or do you somehow score girls by getting them to not talk to you at all? Would love to hear your secrets...
I won't apologize for my advice, I stand by every word of it. If a man has true power over the social situation, he can manipulate his value up and down as he needs to, and more importantly he can effect and manipulate the value and the feelings of those around him, hopefully to the benefit of everyone involved.. Its subtlety. Its finese. He would never worry about "losing his power forever" once he takes a humble step downwards from time to time. He isnt fucking Samson, castrated by some magic haircut. A real man has true control over the situation, and he can and will prove it without hiding behind a wall of denial.