Quote:
I did post this in another thread, but I'm interested in your input, Tripp.
How to "keep in touch" with a girl with a boyfriend..
I dated this girl for a little bit (when I was AFC). We stopped dating and then a month or so later I began talking to her again. We got together once or twice, but I didn't pursue her that aggressively... A month or so later I asked her if she wanted to go to dinner.
She said:
"I would feel funny doing that because I've been dating someone for a few weeks"
I texted back to her (bigtime AFC):
"Call me if it doesn't work out and maybe we'll get together and see how it goes"
She says:
"Ok! Sounds good!"
As you said, very much AFC stuff here.
Quote:
Anyway, we text back and forth fairly regularly. She told me her relationship is already on the rocks-- She says her BF is depressed a lot and she has to cheer him up all the time .
I've persisted some in asking her out.. It's more like:
"I'm going to get some lunch. Want to come with me?"
Still AFC. You actually should have subtely pushed her away a bit.
Quote:
But she won't budge as long as she has a BF, even though I drop "as friends" and "i'm glad we can be friends" periodically.
That, those comments, at this point, will never truly work in this situation. Forget about using them the way you are.
Quote:
I feel like I could have had her back had I pursued her more when she was single.. You snooze, you lose, I guess. My question is, how do I keep in touch with her and periodically probe to see if she is still with him without sounding like a total chump? I think that she does still like me, but she's the shy type and I frankly don't know if she will text me when they break up.
Nope, "pursuing" the way it sounds like you're talking wouldn't have worked either. At this point, if you don't want to sound like a chump, and you don't want to be AFC, you DON'T proble, PERIOD. You can drop a line occasionally. With something funny, or just to literally say "Hey, what's up", something SIMPLE like that, and THAT'S ALL. You DO NOT probe. It won't get you anywhere.
Quote:
I understand "moving on," but I want to win this girl over because last time she knew me, I was AFC. If she falls head over heels for me the second time around, it would validate the progress I have made as a PUA.
I've got to say this . . . if validation is all you want from this girl, that's bullshit. If that's it, then forget about her and move on. Even if it's validating your progress. That's nothing short of using her, and that's bullshit.
Quote:
Just yesterday she texts me:
"Can I ask you a question? I need guy's opinion on something"
"What's up with a guy that is really affectionate at first and says he could see himself marrying me and then be distant and non affectionate the next week?
(she's been with him for about a month, I think)
I respond (AFC, I guess)
"Awful early for this, isn't it? You guys should still be honeymooning."
Then I say (AFC):
"I don't know this guy, so I cannot say anything definitive. However, you shouldn't blame yourself. It could be stress, family problems, or another woman, but it is not your fault."
Yes, THIS statement is where you REALLY messed up on this latest set of messaging. You comforted her, validated her, took the blame off of her, blah blah. Just exactly what she came to you for.
Quote:
She is shy and naive, and it sounds as though she has been played. How do I probe to find out when it is over and then gracefully swoop in to save the day without looking like a chump on standby for her?
Again, you DON'T probe. All you are is her friend that she uses to validate herself with right now. THAT'S IT. You HAVE to push her away a bit. Still be there for her to drop a line to, but don't give her answers, don't give her validation, PERIOD.
And all of this is, on my part, hoping that you aren't using HER for validation as you said.