So the "should I" part relates to social intelligence here more than game per se. Note that I do very much want to keep this social circle in-tact, and preferably not mess things up with the girl I'm currently gaming ("girl #1"), so if you think that's impossible and it's always best to just stick to one girl per social circle, please let me know that. Here's the situation: Girl #1 I met at a birthday party through mutual friends, haven't gotten her out on a date yet. If you want more detail about her and my current issue with getting her out, read
help-getting-this-cutie-out-on-a-date-vt161469.html. If not, it's really not necessary to read that.
On with the relevant info. Girl #2 was not at the party. At the party, the social circle definitely observed that I was into girl #1 and vice versa. One of the pics I had taken and uploaded to Facebook was one with me looking like The Man, with girl #1 and her friend on either side of me. This pic has gotten one comment, by girl #2, saying (translated from Spanish): "oooh who is this hunky man? Introduce please hahaha!" None of our mutual friends have moved to introduce us.
So obviously I haven't met girl #2 yet. I also haven't dated girl #1 yet, but I'd prefer her if you guys tell me I have to choose. Don't get me wrong, girl #2 is definitely cute too, and I'd have no hesitations to go for it if not for girl #1. If you guys think I can still date girl #2 while keeping the social circle in-tact and getting invited back to parties, explain how you would do it. Should I friend and message her myself? Should I like her comment? Should I ask one of our mutual friends to introduce us (even though they know about girl #1)? How should I do it, or why shouldn't I do it?