Quote:
do I really want to be a PUA or do I just want a stable relationship? Gives some things to think about definitely.
It's really funny to me that you ended your post this way because as I was reading the first few paragraphs, I was thinking to myself "What he really wants is emotional intimacy more than anything else."
And that's completely fine. You seem to find yourself attracted to girls that come across as mature, stable, and emotionally open people - who happen to be in good relationships. I would guess that means that you are looking for mature, stable, emotionally open people who are capable of being in good relationships.
If that's the case, you simply need to go out there and "game" in a way that screens for that sort of girl. Ask the "hard" questions about where she is in her life, if she's single and looking, what she's looking for, what kind of relationship she is capable of having at this point in her life. Then, be as open and authentic about how you feel about those things in yourself, even if they are at odds. I love sexually open, emotionally intimate, affectionate, and stable girls. Therefore I need to be open about that. It might seem "beta" to tell a girl that I love affectionate girls and value intimacy and stability, but when I say those things, I am being strong and proud about who I am and saying "If you aren't able to provide that, have a nice day, it was great to meet you."
Sure, you may clash and maybe you won't get laid, but you will be taking control of your dating life to get what you really want. Sure, you will identify emotionally unstable, manipulative, untrustworthy girls who you could bed and have sex with, but you will know that they really can't offer what you are looking for and you will let them pass. You'll screen out X number of girls and those potential hookups, but you will meet that girl that can satisfy you, you will know it from the start via your honesty and authenticity (and her response to it) and you will find that that is worth much more than a bunch of meaningless hookups with girls you didn't align with.
That leads to the all-important question: what is it you really want?
First, being a "PUA" is retarded. Don't fall into the trap of identifying yourself based on your social exploits. Its a deep, dark hole.
Second, if you replace that with "Do I really want to have a lot of casual sex or do I just want a stable relationship?" you arrive at a much better question to be asking yourself. I've said this before but there is nothing wrong with either of those things...if that is what you, and only you, genuinely want as a means of finding fulfillment in your life.
As I sit here, I look back on the last year of my life. Right now, I am in a stable, committed relationship with a girl that lives a pretty long plane ride away. Some would say that's crazy. Many more seem to think its awesome. The truth is what anyone believes about the situation is irrelevant, other than pointing out the people in my life who are supportive and loving.
We have a strong bond and one that we've both agreed that despite the difficult circumstances, is one that as two stable, emotionally, healthy and mature adults, we want to explore. I think this is because we both have been authentic in our communications and in really, genuinely looking into our own emotions and intentions. I have essentially screened her for being a girl that is looking to put a lot of work into making a relationship work, meeting my requirements, and developing this thing over the distance and the obstacles. If I had not done those things, we would be on a long, hurtful road.
Before I met her, I was "at the top of the game." I was getting incredibly sexy, beautiful girls very regularly, but somewhere, deep down I didn't feel content. It should have been easy and straightforward to recognize that but I kept telling myself "I value my independence, I value my flexibility, I value being able to be noncommitted to any girl."
In reality, and I've posted on this before, I simply valued the validation I got from casual sex. I valued it from people who gave me props on that lifestyle. I valued it from the girls I was getting with. My self-worth was getting wrapped up in it. That's not a healthy way to go and eventually, I realized that I just wanted some stable emotional intimacy in my life and that is what I am pursuing. And its been great. And now I am able to find my self-worth independently, from the things that I do and the ways that I live that make me great. One committed girlfriend or 100 casual partners should not be large parts in the security and value I take in myself. Me and only me.
On the other hand, the exact opposite could hold true for someone else. Perhaps their friends or parents or whoever place great significance on being able to hold a stable, secure, intimate relationship. And if they find themselves single, they feel great pressure to get into a relationship, even if really, they don't want to be in one (casual sex or not).
I guess that point is, you really need to dig into your own emotions and evaluate what these things mean to you. And ask yourself if you are motivated by your own desires, by other people's views, or by a lack of self-esteem or worth. Only one of those is the correct answer and the second two are probably pretty inter-related (i.e. low self-worth means acting in a way to impress/please/demonstrate to others even if it is not truly what you want.)
I think you will find that if you look at certain situations such as this one, the writing will be on the wall as to what the proper decision is. I know it certainly was for me, even if I had my back turned to that wall for sometime.