Hey Neo, and RC...
Neo you asked if I did some of the same things in other relationships and yes, I did. But in my other relationships, they never resulted in the actions that she has taken against me, (2 week freeze out, don't text me...) but I am sure there was something.
When I said I'll have 2 weeks of hell dealing with all this, I meant I'll be waiting for her to make up her mind (although I am kinda upset that she personally attacked me in that "break-up" email and that really makes me think about this whole relationship dynamic) and I have the Hawaii thing to figure out as well.
I think RC is correct in that I do believe that she is "afraid of falling in love" as she admitted to being hurt even as recent as last year at this time. She did say to me "I think I am in love with you" but that was it. I loved hearing that and she said that to me just 4 days ago! WTF?
Also RC pinpointed something about me as well. That I really need someone who is up to receiving a higher level of emotional intensity. I don't think she is.
Neo, it is hard to summarize all my past relationship break-ups into a single sentence or two. I've had 2 girls cheat on me. I broke up with a couple when I realized that it was not a good relationship for me.
One of my "issues" is that I trust a girl completely right from the get-go. 100% trust right up-front. I think maybe I need to be more guarded. As far as the Hawaii trip being planned after only being together for a couple of months was that we really, honestly, hit it off fantastically. It seemed a natural thing to just go to Hawaii together.
I have mentioned this before earlier in my post, but it is a strange thing that stays on my mind now...
Every single time we have gone out, she has had a blast! We have NEVER had a "bad date" or an arguement during any of our dates. We ALWAYS had, and have fun and neither she, nor I, can think of even one time that she didn't laugh, enjoy herself, and really appreciate the moments together. I am being completely honest here and not blowing smoke up anyone's ass.
ALL of the "issues" we have had stem from me "overwhelming" her AFTER we've gone out and I'm on my way home, or i'm at home, just totally missing her. That is when I over-text, over-reach, or over-fuck-up.
I was leaving long-ass texts for her, and more recently all I was doing was just telling her I missed her too damn much when we weren't together. Obviously that was way too much and I've still got a lot to learn about being in an Alpha mind-set, but it really did not seem to be that overwhelming to me anyway.
But, I'm also the one doing it, so it is easy to not take the responsibilty for it being too much on her.
The problem is that i still really love this girl, but I think i've pushed her too far.. I want to be with her but I am afraid this "issue" will just keep repeating itself over and over.
I do side with those of us who think after a few days of me being "quiet" she'll come running back...She will totally be wondering why i am not sending her flowers, texting her good-nights, leaving her voicemails... there will be nothing for her to "have" from me during that time. I'd place a bet in favor of that.
Just read how she wrote the break-up letter...She still has me on her gym membership to save me money, she hasn't asked to "return" things to each other, She asked for "about" 2 weeks apart, she did not "cancel out" in her mind the Hawaii trip...things like that...
So I think she is really trying to "punish" me for showing up at the Yoga Studio. I mean, she already said "I'm not texting you until monday" this past Friday because I told her I missed her 3 times in one day, and then she did the "2 week freeze-out' because she was pissed off that we happened to run into each other at the Yoga studio. Shit, I have friends there as well and she didn't even show up there until 15 minutes after I was already there, but that really doesn't matter now...
I am also really looking at the fact that this could very well be a recurring issue between us. Kinda like Neo said. Things are good...I over-do something...She freezes up...She calms down...things are good...i over-do something.... and on and on like that.
I have never, ever, had to deal with a woman who acts this way, and I honestly think it intensifies my reactions towards her when it happens, but I can't dial it back in yet. But at least I am totally aware of what i'm doing now and I can, and I will, work on it.
It makes me think that this type of cycle between us may never end, and she will want to "control" the flow of how, and when, we interact with each other, which won't fly with me at all.
Well Yippie..., I've made it thru one entire 24 hour period without texting her, calling her, or emailing her. I feel like blasting her a new a-hole for how she ripped into me in her email break-up letter, but I have been amazing chill and totally quiet. Very unlike me so far for sure. Usually I scream and shout for her attention...haha!
I think I will continue to do that (be silent and no contact) for the next couple of days at least. I think at that time I should just call her on whether or not we are "together" as I really need to know our status, (kinda obvious though

and also to act fast on the Hawaii thing to recoup some of my money.
Why she can't just roll with me overwhelming her sometimes and say something like: "Dude...you are pushing me into a corner again...haha!" and try to help me stop doing it is beyond me. Damn, it would be easy for both of us and we wouldn't have these big blow-outs like this. kinda just call me on it, take a day to herself if she needed it, and resume again. but, that is making an expectation of her that will never happen.
that's all I got for now... I liked RC's idea of a random basic text to he and it worked fabulously just 4 weeks ago, but i don't think it is a good idea to try that type of thing yet.
Chinopants idea was pretty radical!!! But I think it would be an instant shut-down...