Yeah it sounds as if something non verbal is off. The false time constraint and false roll off is huge when it comes to my dhv stories . I have to know I have them slightly hooked first, I don't just throw my good stories at anyone

the main reason I think my stories are entertaining isn't because of what I'm taking about, but how I say them. Hand gestures, high energy, and overall reason for telling thee story is what gets women invested. Trust me I've told some stories that are really lame but I talked about them in a way that creates interest.
I advise you tell a story to 5 to 10 people this week about how you baked cookies with your grandma. Very lack luster story, but see if you can tell it in a way that people will see as interesting or be able to relate to. Remember, with women, its all about feelings and connections.
Hope that helps. Cheers