Quote:
First of all, I'd like you to slap yourself as hard as you possibly can across the face. Done? Good. Now jab yourself in the left eye as hard as you can. Is it bleeding? Good.
You need your ass kicked for having unprotected sex. You have absolutely no proof that she is free of STDs - hell, you didn't even know she was the type to fuck multiple guys at once. And even with that said, do you really want to run the risk of having a kid with this woman? I think not. Pulling out is ineffective because pre-cum is still likely to impregnate her. Pre-cum is still cum. Never fuck without wrapping it up ever again. For some guys, they need to contract an STD or knock up a girl for him to learn his lesson. Don't be that guy.
Anyway, this type of situation shouldn't be handled with some kind of sneaky, indirect PUA method or anything like that. It's handled by being stern and confident. Tell her you are not the kind of guy to sleep with women who also have these "side projects", and you would prefer to be monogamous or have nothing at all. But, like you said, she doesn't believe in monogamy so this is probably not going to work out. Either let her sleep around or get rid of her.
Take a step back for a bit. What truly makes you feel attracted to her? What would happen if you never had sex with her ever again - would you still be "in love" with her for who she is and nothing more? Answer truthfully, then decide what to do. Oftentimes, if you look at the big picture you'll find that the woman in question is simply only attractive to you because she's a good lay.
I completely agree about the whole condom thing. You should definitely play safe. However, pre-cum will NOT impregnate women. If that were the case, I'd definitely be a father by now (2 year relationship with a Catholic girl). Several testimonies from other PUA's I've chatted with leads me to believe that I am not a special case. Just be sure to use the restroom after you finish / before you start round 2. Just say'n. If anybody would like to refute my claim based on real life experience (and you've had a paternity test), then please step right up.
Anyway, polyamory (or ethical non-monogamy) for the win. It's not weird.. it actually makes a lot of sense. I wrote a whole post about it here:
drama-free-relationships-4-monogamy-vt126038.html
This sounds like a good situation. She likes you and she's being honest with you about what she wants/needs. It's still possible to pursue a non-monogamous long-term relationship with her and you get to sleep with other women if you want. Do some research on polyamory (I recommend this site:
http://www.polyamory.com/forum/ ).
-Wolf