Quote:
I like to get her something cheap and quirky, but pay to share an experience together like a concert, bungy or something more adventurous. She will associate the quirky gift with the experience.
It all depends on the experience being novel, shared, enjoyable and memorable to bring a deep meaning to the quirky cheapo gift.
this. I would always go for organising something to do and then giving her something cheapish and quirky while out doing it unless she has hinted at an actual gift she wants (read expects). personally im london based but my girls not so im gonna cook dinner and then we'll go for theatre and london eye and then ill give some sort of gift on the eye.
doing this is pretty win/win because
1) you both get to enjoy the event (you chose it dumbass, make sure you'll like it!)
2) she will always associate you with that event and place
3) you can completely control the price range while still seeming really generous.
also as blind pointed out if you get a decent, lasting gift (not chocolate or flowers or some shit) she will constantly be reminded of that great day/evening you had and the object itself will be a treasured thing.