I've had a ton of success in the online dating world over the last year, but I just started reading these forums.
I'd like to correct a mistake I've seen repeated like a mantra over and over again here: that the most important thing is "standing out from the crowd" with you profile, and having a "fun" profile, or making yourself seem sexy and mysterious in your profile. WRONG. These are all good and all, but the #1 most important thing by a mile are your
photos.
If you message a girl, 90% of girls will NOT even read your message or your profile if they don't like your photos. Yes, they just click straight to your photos and flip through them, then delete your message and block your profile from their future searches if your photos aren't up to par. So that clever message you spent 10 minutes crafting? Didn't get read, sorry. Your funny and clever profile? Wasn't even a factor if you can't pass the photo test.
I know this because I've talked to dozens and dozens of girls I've met in real life from the dating websites. When I'm on a date with them, many of them haven't even read my profile!!! They see my photos, read my message to them, and respond just from that. They start asking me questions on the date like where am I from, what do I do, etc., and then admit they never read my profile so they have no idea.
Then, once they are fuckbuddies, I'll even cruise their messages on their account with them and watch them as they select guys from the dozens of messages they get every day. They go STRAIGHT TO THE PHOTOS. If they like the photo, then they'll like the message they get from the guy. If they don't like the photos, then the exact same message sent from an ugly guy they will say is a 'creepy' message! lol - sad but true.
Once you pass the photo test, you profile is important. It should show your personality and not be boring. But do not underestimate the importance of your photos. Whatever message you send to the girl is a distant third in importance from your photos and profile.
Tips for your photos:
1) Have a girl look through all your photos on facebook and tell you which are the most flattering ones.
2) have a girl or girls screen your current dating profile photos and make sure any of them aren't unattractive.
3) do NOT put up an unattractive photo of you just because it's cool or you are jumping a walrus with a wakeboard or something crazy. The fact that you look unattractive in the photo is enough to remove it from your profile, even if you're doing something awesome.
4) Start bringing a camera with you when you go out and have people take TONS of pictures of you all the time. Even if you're not photogenic, after a few weeks, you'll be able to find at least SOME photos amongst the plethora of random trash photos that show you from an attractive angle, attractive lighting, out doing something fun, etc.
5) Use the "my best face" feature on OKCupid to have the community rate your photos and tell you which one is the best.
www.okcupid.com/mybestface
6) If worse comes to worse, pay $150 and have a professional photographer take dating website photos of you. They are professionals and can make you look pretty damn good.
PHOTOS > profile > whatever message you write to the girl.