The #1 issue I see with what you're describing is that you are acting. This is at best mentally draining activity, and is usually an affliction of people who are not comfortable simply accepting themselves as they are.
bowlie, you're in a subsection of this forum with a lot of resources to assist you. I'd like to expand on some ideas, but I think using some of the stickies as examples will have a much better effect.
Have you read through the following thread? Specifically, Hobbit's post in this particular thread is noteworthy as it provides tangible tools to move away from acting and into being real. Here is the link:
practical-attainment-of-inner-game-cont ... 67840.html
See if you can take these suggestions and work your way through them, and, as Gaius suggested earlier, keep a journal on this thread documenting at least once a day how these things go for you.