Your story doesn't really add up so I am going to make some assumptions:
*Your girl might be a 9 to you but others probably view her as a 6 or less. She's got way too much time on her hands.
*You view her as more attractive than you thus you view yourself as unattractive or unlikeable by women in general.
*You never initiated a move on her (physically) and you never had sex with her. On the other hand, you might have offered her a few verbal contracts. (I'll be a great boyfriend, we were made for each other, etc . . .)
*In those five years, you haven't had any relationships but you also never tried.
*If a 10 (to you) . . . meaning a girl hotter than this one approached you in those 5 years and offered herself to you, you'd be married right now.
If most of these assumptions are correct, your story would make sense. If not, there's something wrong here.
You negging her drunken kiss long ago plays a minor part but it shows in general that you never showed your attraction for her. Sure, you might have TOLD her that you'd be "great together, etc . . . " but you never swept her emotions through action. You never got her to think, "Wow, this guy is really, really into me."
She knows that you don't have a love life. You don't date, you don't have girls hanging around you and you don't initiate anything. She could marry and divorce 3 times and in 15 years, you'll still be hanging around alone waiting for her. Does this sound exciting to you?
A 'freeze-out', in general is silly but the way it's applied by most in this forum is really sad. You didn't freeze her out in order to attract her. You froze her out because you were pissed you weren't getting any play and your relationship was going nowhere. She knows this. And she also knows that when she's not around, you're jacking off alone in your apartment. All you did was illicit pity from her and pity isn't romantic. You showed her all of your cards. Your message to her is, "Kiss me once in a while and I will hang around you like a little puppy. If you don't kiss me, I will get pissed and go back to my cave for another 6 months." - does this sound like a great potential mate?
Now the interesting part:
You're seeking for advice on how to f-close this girl. Really? This is your best prospect in 5 years? The only reason you're into her is because she teased you once long ago by INITIATING the kiss so you think that it's all a possibility. Your logic is, "Other girls don't give me the time of day. This girl actually tried to kiss me. . . and we smooched a few times after that. (ALL without any special EFFORT from me) There must be something going on here . . . "
Quote:
I've been seeing other girls and she's been seeing other guys. The bad part is that she texts me to ask about my dates and I always play the "they were awesome" which sends her off into a competition of telling me how her dates were great too. I always brush it off and try to avoid the topic.
A blatant and obvious lie to get into her pants? To make yourself feel better? Have you fooled her yet?
I'm pretty sure that I could help you F this girl. Unfortunately, I don't think it will do either of you any good. Soon after, she will once again give you the, "I don't think we should be in a relationship." and you . . . you'd get more pissed than ever before and go back to your cave once again.
You know . . . you can be a shy guy and still run a decent game. But you won't with this girl hanging around making you feel like the best you can do is a few smooches with a 6 in a span of 5 years. Hit the reset button.