Having sarged mostly in Cambridge, UK, I can agree with the original poster's statement:
Quote:
The main difference I have found is that in the UK we are used to a far more subtle approach, whereas in the US girls are used to a much more direct approach.
I don't think you can generalise on such a massive scale, yet this statement does seem to hold true in my experience. A lot of the material is developed for clubs and atomospheres conductive towards pickup. When I first started using community-based ideas, I got results, but a lot of bad sides including excessive shit tests (which can be a good and bad thing).
I realised that I was often more effective pre-pickup days. Having a 'badguy' attitude, C&F etc can easily sway the wrong way, or not accepted well by different HB's.
With all the American-based PU ideas, one can fall into the flowery world of routines, over-showy lines and over-using often unncessary concepts like negs.
I don't know if the difference in girls' attitude here and in America is actually tangible enough to change one's pickup style, and there's no objective way of measuring this.
But certainly subjectively, I have found that except in clubs, a more chilled out, honest, simple and genuine/natural game approach has brought similar if not better results, but more importantly, SATISFYING results, because I enjoy the pickup more and I am just me; it's sustainable after the close too.