Ok Guitar_Whizz, you seem to have quite a few things wrong with the way you view indirect PUA, so I'll do what I can here to clear it up for you (Though, to be honest, I don’t think you'll listen anyway).
Quote:
It's like some weird cult or something with all the PU clones running around using the same canned routines.
I won’t deny that this happens, but I can tell you that it is profoundly wrong and not a reflection of what a good indirect PUA is. Canned routines and openers are
training wheels that rAFC's use to induct themselves into the game. You use those until you have the inner game to run your game without the need for them. That is ALL they are there for.
As for everyone using the same ones, this is something else that happens that really shouldn’t. True indirect PUA teaches that everyone should make up their own openers and DHV's and work them. If they don’t, you are right and they are lying and putting on a fake mask in order to pick up.
Quote:
What happens when you do canned game is you become a flawed character, in that you become really incongruent and fake. You literally have a 'fake outer layer' that you're using to attract girls.
Again, this happens, but it shouldn’t. A true PuA changes his personality to become more attractive. It's not some mask you wear, or a way of speaking, if you want it to happen, you have to LIVE it. It should be a part of you. You change yourself to be a better person.
So yes, there are some 'puas' (if you could call them that) that do this, and, I'll be blunt, I don’t know how well it works for them, but I can’t imagine it's very well.
Quote:
Direct works on the basis that some girls will like you, some girls won't, and your job is to find a girl that a)you like and b)also likes you. The trouble with the 'canned game guys' is they've bought into this bullshit lie that it's somehow possible to 'get any girl'. Well let me tell you, that is complete horseshit, as no guy on this earth can pull ANY girl.
The truth is, some girls like you, some don't, end of.
Fair enough, I can see that working for some, but it's certainly not my cup of tea. Indirect game works on the basis that you can be friendly and interesting to most (I would generally use 'any', but It’s true that you'll find the rare girl that just doesn’t) girls in a non-threatening way such that you can have the best chance at conveying your attractive personality and traits to them, which gives you the best chance with them.
It's all about maximizing what you have, and generating opportunities to show that to girls.
Naturally, you will never be able to pull 'any' girl, but using indirect methods, you give yourself the best possible chance with every girl you open.
Quote:
The thing about me saying 'You're the most beautiful girl I've seen all day' is that it's not a line or a routine, it's just me being truthful and honest about my desires.
I didn’t want to have a go at you at all in this post (That's just poor form), but to be honest, that's a lie. 'You're the most beautiful girl I've seen all day' is a line through and through.
It you wanted to be truthful and honest about your desires, you would say "I think you're attractive and would like to have sex with you" to girls. To which, they would probably not react so well. You mask your desires (Albeit, a lot less than indirect game does) for the purposes of maximizing your chances with said girl.
Quote:
I am already starting to get Direct/Authentic seduction calibrated and it's just a matter of time before I start getting instant dates, makeouts, numbers and lays from it.
I don’t doubt this, and to be honest, I'll be jealous of you when you get this working. As I am now, I can’t see me being able to pull off direct game in the slightest.
Quote:
...this is a PUA forum....i.e. indirect, canned, manipulative, technique based game....the complete opposite of what Direct is all about.
Hardly. Indirect PuA is not manipulative, though I'll admit it can be a little deceptive at times. Though honestly, I don’t think it's such a bad thing to feign disinterest in a girl for the purposes of making her more comfortable talking to you.
In summary; Direct is about being forward and proactive in demonstrating your interest in a girl with the hope of a positive response. It uses good body language, confidence and congruence with self as its main tools of attraction.
Indirect is about making the target feel comfortable and not threatened around you so that you have the best chance of conveying your higher value to her.
To each his own, but I have far more success with girls using indirect game, where I can hold a meaningful and fun conversation with them before I decide if I like them enough to continue. This is my personal style and opinion, so take it as you will.
If you can get direct game to work for you, good for you, but know that Indirect pua is not fake or manipulative, just a different approach to the same goal.