Ok this happened to me a few days ago, me and this HB were talking before class started about something random, but she asked If I had heard about this girl who had committed suicide by hanging herself, and she made some comment about crazy people and I decided to fuck with her so I got real serious and said "I knew that girl..." The HB got all flustered and started to apologize and I just cracked a huge smile and said "I'm lying, I was just trying to make you feel like an asshole." She smiled and punched me on the shoulder and called me a jackass but yeah.

So any ideas on how that might be or even should be turned into a routine?

This should not be turned into a routine. If the girl brings the subject up I would change it quickly. You don't want to be associated mentally w/ morbid subject matter. Unless she's into fucking the dead.

It's true, you don't want her to associate you with morbid and depressing things and of course if you want to do something with her you don't want her to think of you as some guy that just makes her feel sad when she's around you, and I have a question myself, am a high school aged PUA myself but are you?

Normally, I'd say something like, way to bump a dead topic. But, I'm glad you did. Because Mr. Fantastic's last sentence made me laugh uncontrollably. Thanks Buddy