I have two comments to this:
1) Who are you to deem that lifestyle isn't attractive? You don't think he has interesting stories, which convey traits about him and his life from meeting so many different people? He is meeting women every night, which means he is social. You don't know how he came to his position, he may have once had a different lifestyle or environment that socialized him correctly.
Don't be so quick to judge. I once had a conversation with a janitor at Tulane University in New Orleans from around midnight to 6 a.m. He introduced me to a fellow janitor who was educated and smarter than most of the people he cleaned after. But none of the students knew that. I think about that conversation before I start judging people.

People working to improve all aspects of their lives shouldn't be labeled as trying to become naturals. Because naturals are not actively working to improve their life; therefore, we are not striving to be them.

We are working to be naturally attractive - an ATTRIBUTE we share with people who are naturally good at picking up women.

I'm a little pressed for time, so I can't read the whole thread right now, but I'd just like to give my quick 2 cents.

You mentioned that just because they are naturally good with women, doesn't mean that they are happy and well rounded people. Although this is the IDEAL outcome for a PUA, whether 3rd generation or otherwise, I have to say that I see just as many, if not MORE unhappy PUAs around, because they put so much emphasis on being able to pick up women. Not all do and they're what we hope men become, but many think the only reason to be here is to learn to get with women and if they aren't doing that, then their lives aren't fulfilled. There's also a lot of men that go about learning the skills in order to be able to manipulate women and aren't particularly enviable people, or anyone I'd care to associate with.

Just cause you want PUAs to be great people, doesn't make it so. Just because we have an ideal in mind, doesn't mean other people subscribe to it. Just because we think of ourselves as being righteous and good people, doesn't always make it true.

That being said, I wish I could remember the line from fight club, because I DO see some of the best men and women around the world, here in the community; men and women that have dedicated themselves to becoming the best they can be, which is what makes me truly respect a person, regardless of where they are currently at in life/skill. We work towards that ideal of being better, but don't allow yourself to be fooled into believing we have already attained that goal just because we value it so much and hold it in highest regards. We continually strive to better ourselves, yet that doesn't mean we are better than others.

As a final note, just because I often sound like I am preaching from a soapbox, doesn't mean I believe I am any better than the people I preach to. I speak my beliefs and my ideals, yet I know I am still a flawed creature and have far to travel before I have attained what I hope one day to achieve.