So I noticed girls are more likely to open messages if the subject line is catchy or funny.

Any suggestions will do, feel free to post! Thanks.

I don't know, man. Feels like you're trying to hard. I use titles like, "Some friendly advice" and have not had a problem getting the message read or responded to.

Good luck.

Hey guys, I’ve been doing online dating for a couple months now (very frustrating in the beginning) but with some experimenting and research, found couple things that worked:
-the Profile can NOT be serious. (Profession: Professional Coffee Brewer)
-Silly subject line (“We’re robbing a bank need a driver”)
-Profile should show that I’m selective (“Must have a college degree”)
I think we should experiment and practice a few times before we get consistent results. We need to fail sometimes so we can adjust and find another way to do it right. I got some great ideas from researching online and Cajun’s stuff has been really helpful. He’s got some free chapters on online game: http://bit.ly/xG1Yej

Mate, just put two random words that first come to your head..
slippery nipples
ninja monkey
gorilla poker
uaresofreakinghotdotcom

90% off the time, they will ask what the subject title is about. then you reply with something like 'You never answered my questions..'

_________________
We are here for a Good time, Not a long time.
Chick Count - 190

The problem with your question, is that PoF removed the ability to use subject lines in your messages, a few months ago.

^^^ they've incorporated the changes at various times throughout different areas, I think. My area just switched to no subject a few weeks ago. I'd heard about this in other forums a few weeks before and was wondering wtf.