TLDR; Having sex with one girl, want to start having sex with another. The other is the jealious type and knows that im having sex with the first girl. She claims she won't have sex with me till i give up the first girl.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Basis: Girl that doesn't go to my college but we meet up a lot and have sex, and i am emotionally connected to her. Her name is Morgan1.

New college girl's name is Emily2
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
I have this group of two other girls that i hang out with, one has a boyfriend and she's just chill. Then the second girl is the one i am into, Emily2.

We three hang together a lot, and we talk about everything. Including relationships and sex.

Emily2 is still having sex with her ex, and is emotionally connected to him. She also knows that i'm having sex with Morgan1, and she knows that i am into her.

For the first time today, i invited Emily2 too dinner, alone. This is the first time we have hung out just us two. I could see that she's starting to want to get around more. Mabye to make her boyfriend jealious or what. To be honest, doesn't matter to much to me.

As we were eating after a light happy conversation. I brought up the idea of us being friends with benifits / fuckbuddies. Once again to my surprise she was into the idea. Although she is the jealious type and says she couldn't do it knowing i would still be fucking Morgan1.

In this situation, would it be a good move to lie, and say i wouldn't be having sex with Morgan1 anymore? Or just talk her into the idea more. Or neither if you guys propose something else? As long as it's not move on lol

_________________
"There is no failure. Only feedback." ~Robert Allen

My most helpful mentors:
Much thanks too;
Eddie Fews
PEBBLE
R.C.

So she's having sex with her ex but can't have you having sex with Morgan? lol.

Dude, just ask her over for netflix and chill. Then, start turning her on, kiss her neck, all that. See where it leads.

I don't really know why you had a conversation about this before having sex, but anyway, point is, listen to her actions, not her words.

So no, absolutely do not lie, that's just fucked up and it will backfire in your face - point blank. And logically talking a woman into going against her feelings (of jealousy in this case)... yeah, good luck with that, lol.

As I've said, have her over an escalate. You already know the interest is there. She will give you LMR, but you could always over-come it. Sex doesn't have to happen the first time, but you should still escalate as much as possible. You want to make her horny, not uncomfortable.
So if you wanna avoid buyers remorse and turn this into a regular thing, don't go full caveman, unless you can.

_________________
I know my place. It's me on top of the world.

My in depth texting & dating guide.
There's no such thing as shit-tests.
How to keep a girl.

Definitely possible. Just stay away from making rules and conditions. As a matter of fact, the only thing that I didn't like that you've done was discuss the idea. You should have done as R.C. suggested...ask her over, escalate and fuck. From there you can easily say that you guys shouldn't be setting rules because what you guys currently have is easy and no stress. She'll follow your lead from there.

_________________
mpuaforum.proboards.com