hey peps , i am a 20 year old student that has the same problem over the course of years. i am a very good looking guy , blonde eyes ( girls always tell me i am cute and stuff like that) and a perfect almost holywood white smile ( i know

). i had some game before but with styles book i got in all of this PUA stuff.
basiclly my problem is that i always attract the girls i dont like as opposed to the girls i like are not attracted to me at all. i get alot of attention and am really relaxed around girls and there are always atleast 2 in my company because i can make them laugh and shit so it isnt that i am not good with girls in total.
there is the "try hard part" but i just do the same stuff i do with the rest of the girls , bit of cocky funny , maybe some DHV routines , cube ,ring routine and ofc natural game etc. but i cant seem to get the girl i want to get.
example now
at wednesday we had a big party with my student NGO ( i am in 5 NGO-s + politcal party + student body council for my year ) and there were 2 new girl there . i immediately spotted 1 that i liked ( 8 hb) and she was with her friend ( 7.5). so i first got to her friend , got her laughing and in good mood then switched to my " target"(8hb). but she just seemed to to be cold and not giving me any signals. i talked to her for 20 min , then danced with soem of my other friends and then sat down. then a girl ( 18 year ) which is in same NGO as i am got up to me sat down and just kissed me and started to heavy kino me ( 8.5 hb).
but same thing happens over and over again , i get hot girls alot but the girls i like i cant seem to get at all.
any help would be appreciative