So this girl and I have been talking for the past couple of months. I first met her back when I was in highschool, me of course being that awesome guy whose attention was always being demanded. (And I say was because being an at home student I don't go out every day like I used to) Anyways, so I was walking at the hallway at my church after the service had ended when to my right side I see this gorgeous girl with wavy brown hair, dark brown eyes, in a black dress that just left me

, when I realize, Its THAT sporty girl from high school. This girl is a gymnast and a just good at any sport.. and shes a gymnast. Okay?
Soo I go a little out of my way enough so she notices I am there. Boom, we end up exchanging facebooks, so when I get home I message her that it was nice to see her there. We talked for a couple of months, teased and kept the momentum going for as long as I could, being hard for us to meet up becuse of her busier schedule making her flake a couple dates, except at church. So much for waiting so long....sigh, I lost interest and I froze her after a very nice chat. (Shh, I know what Im doing)
TLDR: Anyways, exactly one month after I froze her, I coincidentally bumped into her on her birthday. She was throwing IOI's all over, I love how they move their eyes. She ended up inviting me for dinner the next day she has available

. So my question to you guys is: What would you do in this situation? (I havnt given her any gifts yet, but I'll sure be bringing her a thoughtful little one).