Ones I respond to are usually complimentary or a neg...but not complimentary in a crude way like 'you've got bedroom eyes'...'wanna f*ck', 'here's my cell number, email address etc', 'wow you're stunning'...or even 'you look interesting'!
They're either way too strong and obvious you just want cyber sex or to meet up and have sex, or they're nothing that makes you WANT to reply!
So I guess, I would maybe tease them about something they have written on their profile, a song/band/TV show (have said this before I know) and see if that works...but don't sound too cocky, in an email they can't see that you're half kidding
You could try this kind of thing: Hi (insert their screename so it doesn't sound generic), I'm new to myspace and came across your profile, thought you sounded interesting, particularly your liking of (XYZ, insert something to make it sound again like you read her profile, not a generic email you send everyone), nice pics, saw your friend list and don't you think I'd look good on it?
That's off the top of my head...you may not like, I will try and think of ones I am likley to respond to. I hate to say it but your pics can make a huge difference to if someone replies. If your pic is you looking creepy/too wacky/too posey/fake...that all may be reasons why they don't reply too.
Red (with a sore head this morning from too much wine last night!)
x