Hey I need some help with the comfort building stage (I think) here is my approach on POF:

1st message (80% reply rate)

Hey I wouldn't message you unless you were attractive but a friend of mine noticed that you have a simple profile, looks like made by a guy...now we have a bet going...are you a real girl?

Response (along the lines of) : haha no I am real you win the bet

So I tried A, B and C with little success and this is where I need help!!

A) 2nd message (5% reply rate)

Haha great so what brings you to POF

B) 2nd message (10% reply rate)

Sweet I knew it, ok let me ask you a few things

1. Something from the profile
2. Do you make a good gf
3. Have you been in love

C) 2nd message (5% reply rate)

Great, do you have Facebook to prove you are a real person

What is a good 2nd message and what am I doing wrong here. Any help would be great. Thanks