Great post.
Apparently I am the 'Tinder guy' around here and this is a great lesson to be learned. But personally, I use all channels to my advantage to diversify. I find a lot of people tend to stick to one or the other and are a little bit closed minded.
Day, night, online, couch surfing - they all generate girls to meet
Online is great in the sense that it filters all the single girls that are looking to meet in one channel for you to sort through. It's like being on a planet where there is only single people.
But there is nothing more primal than being in her face and projecting eliciting sexual tension and turning her on with your vibe. This is way more powerful than the best quality picture of you saving a kitten from a burning house.
Most importantly...Did you tell her that she ditched you on POF after you banged her?
Something the opposite happened to me recently...I had this situation where I made out with a hot a girl in a club, she flaked. A month later I get matched with her on Tinder and she was keen. I told her that I made out with her and she remembered.
She then suddenly flaked.
I guess there was something in person that she was turned off by me (Maybe it was my Halloween costume)
I don't know why I told her that. Lesson learned.