May I add my own two cents?
You see, I befriended a guy who was naturally good with women - VERY good even...and he taught me many things. He basically braught me up into the game before I've even heard of the community's existence.
One day, I asked him for advice because there were two girls I liked and talked to - but they found out and called me a player. I feared getting a reputation..and he taught me one of the most valuable lessons
on reputation, being called a "player"...
Here's a lesson on female psychology:
- If you had so many women, other females will think there most be something about you that makes you so desirable...why would all those
women otherwise want you? It feeds her curiosity, and a dirty motivator is also at play here: we want what everyone else is having, the human drive of competition my friend: the grass is always greener on the other side, and she wants to lay in it, play in it, make love in it...
- If you had so many women but DON'T want her, they automically assume that there must be something wrong not with you but with THEM: all of us have a tendency to identify ourselves as the cause of the problem as soon as love and attraction come around the corner..."no it's all my fault honey, no really, I'm so sorry" while you didn't do any friggin' thing, it's the typical relationship fight, friend. She will want to know why SHE isn't an object of your desire while all women seem to be, maybe she is less of a woman?
And because of these reasons, whether they think it consciously or subconsciously, they secretly actually want to find out...find out A)WHY you are so attractive to other women, B) if they can tame you and have you all to themselves (every woman's fantasy: taming the badboy) and C) WHAT'S the reason for you turning them down..
So really, I would laugh if she said it...
As a sidenote: if you try to explain yourself, she will feel that you need to PROVE her wrong...prove her otherwise...so that she's actually right. Laughing about it lets her know: you think it's ridiculous, and so will she. You want to disarm HER, not defend yourself...because defense means guilt in a woman's mind...think about it
So the majority of the times, I smile when I hear of my reputation..because I know the effects

and when I really sense a lot of anger on the spot? I laugh, and tell her don't be silly...you'd be surprised about how many women will think differently about you afterwards..