let's get a little more concrete here instead of dropping alpha theory which doesn't necessarily translate into usable, beneficial action.
first, OP your intuition that the "take it or leave it" response created a weak frame was correct. it's butthurt and predictable on the heels of her saying she needs to slow it down. the correct response is to text her "slow what down" (it's a question of course, but if you're texting it you omit the question mark to strengthen the quickness and offhandedness of the response), and then to proceed as though you're playfully confused as to why she thinks you two are exclusive, or that you're only after her and don't have other women literally all over you (all of which is implied in your tone and attitude, and never stated explicitly). then you reduce contact and make her chase you by freezing her out a bit and gaming other girls.
Quote:
She goes home for a bit, and texts me in the middle of it saying she wants to slow down.
aka "i've been hanging out with another guy and i'm not sure which of you i like more, so i'm gonna string both of you along until the most alpha proves himself." this is almost always the case if you're getting a text like this. a girl who is absolutely crazy about you does not send this whatsoever.
Quote:
Anyway, she wanted to chat tonight, but I said I'm busy and let's grab a drink tomorrow night.
well-played. you don't chat with chicks who want to slow things down. you meet to get drinks, you game them, you take them home and you bang them. then you kick them out because you are a busy fellow and they do not deserve "relationship" perks until they have proven themselves.
Quote:
To me, it seems like demanding an exclusive relationship implies a bit of neediness, at some level.
Ha! a bit?! you demand an exclusive relationship with a girl you've been dating for 3 weeks?! ludicrous. insane. doomed. worst of all, needy as fuck.
always let the girl initiate the "i want to be in a relationship" communication.
Quote:
Do you think there is a middle ground here, where I can say let's take things slower, but if you choose to become involved with anyone but me, we're through?
think of how controlling and needy this sounds my good man. there is a middle ground, and you can do these things, but what you cannot do is
say them to her. it's reverse psychology that you need. you need to be
giving off a vibe that screams, "i don't give a fuck who you get involved with because i'm involved with a truckload of other women right now, and there's just no way i'm sacrificing this bad ass life i have to be your boyfriend." regardless of whether that's even the case, you need to emit that particular vibe. because right now her interest level in you is falling fast, so any sort of direct "take it or leave it" response is gonna push her away even further.
Quote:
I fully agree with Jacks advice, but at least find out what she's talking about or what she means before choosing something. She could mean take it slow sexual, she could be that you two were spending too much time together and she needs to get stuff done, she could mean she wants to date around. Just communicate with her before you go strategic.
hmm, a text in the middle of an extended period where she hasn't seen him for a while is almost guaranteed to be serious and not just slowing down sex or anything light/easily repairable. and it's almost always another guy involved. ex-boyfriend, new crush, etc.. an outside chance perhaps that OP's getting too needy and turning her off i guess... not really though.
and asking her to explain herself so that you are forced to hear the brutal truth puts you in a weak frame imo. i'd just assume and act as though it's another guy or that OP is getting too needy and killing attraction prematurely. but generally it's another guy, to be honest. always been the case in my experience.
not sure i agree with jackzero's approach here. if you want a relationship with a woman, it's not really helpful for you to have a "take it or leave it" attitude this early. it's tantamount to you walking up to a woman in a bar and saying "marry me, right now. take it or leave it." well that's great. you're alpha and know what you want i guess... but no woman worth her salt is taking you up on that offer.
you have to attract her. make her chase you. be vague. be mysterious. fill her with doubt as to whether you even really like her. this is the way of the world. and 3 weeks is not nearly enough time for a girl to know she wants to exclusively date you and be your gf. if, by 3-4 months of exclusive fucking and dating, you're still in this spot, then yes you need to figure out what the fucking deal is.
but right now, here's what you do:
-reduce overall contact dramatically.
-make her habitually contact you first. be brief in response. be mysterious.
-(this is absolutely the most important and most failed step) maintain a positive, cheerful, cocky, sexual demeanor in all interactions. tease her. flirt with her. you don't hate her. you're just busy fucking other women.
-do not talk about deep or serious shit with her whatsoever. you're not her bf.
-game other women on the side. if you can, post photos of you and other women on social media.
-never mention a relationship or exclusivity again unless it is in response to her seeking it, in which case you respond playfully and affirmatively after deliberation. (e.g: so you wanna lock me away in your bedroom huh?)
Quote:
From here on out, my game plan is: 1) agreeing that we should slow it down, and joking about her getting too clingy anyway; 2) raw confidence/aloof assurance; 3) being more unavailable to her.
everything but 1 buddy. don't even mention it.
you don't have to have this "talk" everyone here is advising you to have. it kills literally all attraction. you haven't been married for 20 years for the love of god. just don't bring the shit up. if she brings it up, smirk at her and change the fucking subject. you have all the power in the world. she's not gonna keep hampering on it over and over. and if she does? get up and leave, because she's trying to break up with you anyways.
good luck, and please report back. if you wanna flesh things out some more that's cool. but this is the general gameplan i'd employ were i in your situation.