Another little update, HBX indeed spent the night saturday, she even got her girlfriend to drop her off because she couldnt bike through the snow, she really put some effort into coming over, I was amazed (she didnt do that when we were a couple before we broke up).
She wanted it, she even told me, but the sex was..well..not really there? I think she was nervous (so was I btw, for some reason) because I couldnt possibly get in, I tried lubed condoms, lube, and without. That caused me to go limp every fucking time I tried and after a while we just gave up, I asked her if she was relaxed, fingered her for 30 minutes, massaged her, everything I could think of. We tried again at 6 in the morning and again at 11 in the morning, couldn't fucking get it in! I had trouble with that before with her because she's a really, really small/petite girl with an equally small vagina (she turns 18 next month don't know if that is a factor here). Pretty much a bummer, she was bummed out and I told her I liked her no matter what (I really do). We got out of bed, had breakfast, watched the football game and she went home. We haven't had that much contact since, some texting, but less than usual. I'm not gonna overthink things and just give her some space.
HBM just texted me, she wants to come over for wine and a movie fridaynight, and spend the night (she has to get up early on saturday to go dance near my place). I'll go for the kiss at my place and try to escalate into an F-close. I told her she could sleep on the couch if she behaves haha.
Oh yeah and I told HBY that I couldnt see her anymore because she felt so much more for me than I did for her and I felt guilty about it, I can still bootycall her though. At least now I got rid of the annoying 24/7 texts from HBY.
I've decided I'm just gonna take it slow with HBX and see how friday night goes with HBM.
Thanks all for the responses by the way.
And Chelios: in my last update I said that she has another fuckbuddy, and that she's not interested in a LTR (i am, im just not sure if she's the one i want to have a LTR with ;D), she told me she wants me, but I dont want to share her
