I've collected lipstick, neon panties (who would forget that ) , a brush, a black skirt

Things that didn't make the list : scrunchies, girl writing on whiteboard, and those hair clips

All the time. I have a feeling it's primal. However I must admit, I don't fucking know, maybe they just think "I want to come back".

One time a girl left her panties that were soaking wet with cum at mine. I put them in my draw and forgot about them for weeks. Pulled them out and they were like paper mache.

Absolutely.

I keep a lost in found bin. Its a marking of territory. Something for your other girls to find if you have anyway.

Funny thing is, I would find items like earrings in weird places in my house and based on the style of it try to figure out who it came from. I'd then text a girl i hadn't spoken to in months to say " Is this yours? ".. Genuinely.. Not even interested in anything. And they'd response " Nope ". And then suddenly be reinterested in me all over again. Texting, calling, trying to see me again etc.